The government of Norway is now threatening to close down any company which does not have more than 40% women in the boardrooms by 2007. Nowhere is radical feminism as strong as in the Scandinavian Peninsula and the thought of low female representation in board rooms having anything to do with sex differences in preferences or distribution of abilities rather male chauvinist discrimation is of course even more taboo than in Harvard. The Swedish government have also told companies to have more than 40% women in the boardrooms, but have not (yet) decided to impose any punishment on companies that do not comply.
Source link: http://archive.mises.org/3445/norwegian-government-to-force-companies-to-have-more-female-board-members/
Norwegian government to force companies to have more female board members
Previous post: Shocking news: Greenspan says credit expansion is a good thing
Next post: Bernanke the next Fed Chair?



{ 36 comments }
Too funny. Maybe all the least competent businesswomen in the world can move to Norway for a guaranteed welfare income.
I’d be willing to bet that they won’t even be able to find enough Norwegian women who actually want to sit on some board…
So, the gov’t of Norway thinks women are worth 2/3 of a man (40%/60%). Why the inequality – why not a 50-50 split?
Vanmind
The incompetence is within yourself, Vanmind(Vain mind)
Danny Taggart wrote: “So, the gov’t of Norway thinks women are worth 2/3 of a man (40%/60%). Why the inequality – why not a 50-50 split?”
I do not support ideas like this at all, but as you most likely understand that is not the point at all. The goal is not to have a 50/50 representation at all times, but to be somewhat close to it. A situation with 40% women OR men is considered equal enough.
Of course, this idea will not do any good, but I do like to keep the discussion focused on the right questions. Comments like yours doesn’t help.
“Of course, this idea will not do any good, but I do like to keep the discussion focused on the right questions. Comments like yours doesn’t help.”
You clearly missed the obvious when you read his post.
[sarcasm]Obviously, businesses are not in business to provide desired goods and services, but to provide jobs and help socio-engineer the politically correct society.[/sarcasm]
VanMind’s right in one way-board member composition is a reflection of society, good or bad. Laws like these are impotently attacking a symptom of societal views, and can do nothing about the cause.
Being the state situation as is it and along with the tradition of norvegians, I found quite wright this mesure. I loved a beautiful norvegian paintress many years ago and found her so sage and flexible, as her friends, they merit this encouragement. However, before entering the board meeting, it’s also necessary to make to the MEN an alcholic trial like for drivers of car.
It’s amazing to think the Vikings, who were the baddest, and in my opinion the awesomest, bunch going so many years ago have decendents who embrace this hyper-egalitarianism that will bring them nothing but stagnation. (Note: I don’t endorse rape and pillage but longboats and mead are damn cool.) I have no pity for the Scandi-statists who will reap the results of their stupidity. The Nordic “peoples states” are in for a world of hurt (you’d know that better than anyone, eh Danny T.? BTW- right on about the 50/50 split.)
-Paul
Name ForRep.Ron
Wrote: I have no pity for the Scandi-statists who
will reap the results of their stupidity. The Nordic “peoples states” are in for a world of hurt.
Reaping the results of their stupidity, Americans know a lot about that don’t they.
Heh, there are liberals every where in the world Rolf
Rolf- Being an American, I can say: Yes. However, I wasn’t the brainiac who dreamt up the New Deal or Great Society, so I can’t be collective-guilted into accepting blame for it
NameedForRep.Ron
I have for many years very much enjoyed the work of one of your great American poets, Philip Levine who I can imagine you yourself have also read. A timeless poem. “They Feed They Lion”
Enjoy:)
They Feed They Lion
Out of burlap sacks, out of bearing butter,
Out of black bean and wet slate bread,
Out of the acids of rage, the candor of tar,
Out of creosote, gasoline, drive shafts, wooden dollies,
They Lion grow.
Out of the gray hills
Of industrial barns, out of rain, out of bus ride,
West Virgina to Kiss My Ass, out of buried aunties,
Mothers hardening like pounded stumps, out of stumps,
They Lion grow.
Earth is eating trees, fence posts,
Gutted cars, earth is calling in her little ones,
“Come home, Come home!” From pig balls,
From the ferosity of pig driven to holiness,
From the furred ear and the full jowl come
The repose of the hung belly, from the purpose
They Lion grow.
From the sweet glues of the trotters
Come the sweet kinks of the fist, from the full flower
Of the hams the thorax of caves,
From “Bow Down” come “Rise Up,”
Come they Lion from the reeds of shovels,
The grained arm that pulls the hands,
They Lion grow.
From all my white sins forgiven, they feed,
From my car passing under the stars,
They Lion, from my children inherit,
From the oak turned to a wall they Lion,
‘From they sack and they belly opened
And all that was hidden burning on the oil-stained earth
They feed they lion and he comes.
By Philip Levine From C.A.P 1990
Despite the comments of some of the most obvious statists, the idea of making a company hire 40% of its boardroom with women will most likely become a bureaucratic nightmare, once the Scandinavian goverments create yet ANOTHER agency to keep tabs on the different boardrooms. Such intrusion will make business life more difficult for these companies. A consequence of this could be that less constricted companies will whittle away the market for these companies, most of which are exporters or multinationals – they must be, or they would be dead long ago.
Another thing: where will they get the women to man the boardrooms? Once they are hired, and find them wanting in their capabilities, how will these companies replace them? Will the government allow the companies to fire them?
Some of the comments that seem in favor of this policy do not stop and think about the unintended consequences of government interference. It will not help women achieve a level of parity with men, because such level was not sought after in the first place.
Rolf – Vanmind is using sarcasm to press a valid point; the insult was not called for.
Perrosuelto – There is no need to say that there are competent women out there, and companies do hire competent women for their boardrooms. The thing is that interventionists seem to think that the job is highly sought after by all women, which I do not think is the case. Many women I know (all sharp and smart) do not like the rat-race environment of the high profile company job – actually, few men friends I have like it either.
Francisco Torres
Your points are well put forth and such may be the case. The problems have been well researched in Norway.
The structures in Norway and its culture is much better understood by Norweigns themselves than outsiders. It is a country with a 1000 year old history, a population of 4.4 million people who know their own needs much better than outsiders.
Some Americans need to learn to stop interfering in other countries affairs. Some Americans have gotten themselves into messes time after time after time because they do not have a clue about any other cultures than their own. Some Americans are culture blind and the tragedy of it can be see every where in the world.
There is an old chinese proverb which states: Put your own house in order before you talk about the order of your neighbors house.
Why is it so difficult for some Americans to learn that?
As for Vanmind, the arrogance clearly came through in the post.The post was an insult to women in general. It is not necessary to insult whole groups of people. All human beings are at different levels of human development, no two having the same competance level in any area.
Fairness is an ongoing consideration throughout the Norweign society. It is about power sharing.
And for far to long through out the world women have not had their rightfull well deserved place.
The brutes have dominated everywhere and then tried to convince everyone only they were competent. There would be far less kaos and wars in the world if it was women who dominated for I very much doubt that they would be so willing to send their daughters to war to murder other womens daughters.
Rolf, just in case you didn’t see, it says to post “an intelligent and civil comment”. Emphasis here being on the intelligent part.
Nobody (including Americans) on this board suggested taking over Norway, and forcing out the idiots who dream up these egalitarian schemes. If anything, we want to laugh at the stupidity which passes for “culture” in your circles. Or will you send your women here take over our boardrooms?
Mr. Iceberg
You need to finish high school.
It’s worth mentioning that this only applies to public corporations, correct? Surely one can’t be surprised, upon receiving a government charter for a “public” corporation with special government privileges, that the government now wants to cause as much regulation and interference as possible.
Rolf, you need to stick to intelligent arguments not juvenile insults.
I demand 1 place in each board be reserved for a homosexual, another for someone with red hair, and a randomly selected one in every 10 boards be required to include either a dwarf or someone who suffers from gigantism.
Since someone born a woman had no more choice in that than I do having been born an american, I want a seat on a board too!
Paul D
I had thought you were above insults paul d.
I conclude my presence here in this one sided insult exchange with this passing observation.
Put order into your own house before telling your neighbor about the disorder in your neighbors house.
For the simple reason known as “Credibility”.
America isn’t “my house” any more than Norway is yours, you nationalist pig.
I’ll remember your phrase next time I see someone being raped, “better put my own house in order first, garden looks a bit dishevelled, can’t say anything bout rapist till I am perfect myself”
Get a grip.
Rolf is absolutely wright. For one, the big nationalist pigs are the americans in general, just see there stupids comments from degenerate people, hoping in an ideal world that NOT EXIST ever under their own empire. Some comments, like despreciate culture, other countries etc. are symptoms of frustrated people that just heard some “egalitarism”-like-behavior, become fould and paranoic. Norvey has all my respect, as any other tradition different to idiot conformism that a society MUST be a pulverized of aggregates individuals. Back into forest!
Rolf wrote:
“The problems have been well researched in Norway.
The structures in Norway and its culture is much better understood by Norweigns themselves than outsiders. It is a country with a 1000 year old history, a population of 4.4 million people who know their own needs much better than outsiders.”
Your comment begs the question: If the 4.4 million Norwegians know their own needs, why would they need to have “their needs” forced upon them my government mandate? Wouldn’t the individual Norwegians WHO SUPPOSEDLY KNOW BETTER, come up with the 40%+ proportion of female board members by themselves, without coercion?
Rolf wrote:
“Some Americans need to learn to stop interfering in other countries affairs. Some Americans have gotten themselves into messes time after time after time because they do not have a clue about any other cultures than their own. Some Americans are culture blind and the tragedy of it can be see every where in the world.”
What does this have to do with the issue? I do not understand the purpose for your rant.
Rolf wrote:
“There is an old chinese proverb which states: Put your own house in order before you talk about the order of your neighbors house.”
The article was posted by Stefan Karlsson, who if memory serves is a Scandinavian, not an American. BTW I’m not an American either, but Mexican.
Rolf wrote:
“As for Vanmind, the arrogance clearly came through in the post.The post was an insult to women in general.”
Oh, give me a break! You speak for all women in the world now?
Rolf wrote:
“It is not necessary to insult whole groups of
people.”
He didn’t. Read the post again.
Rolf wrote:
“All human beings are at different levels of human development, no two having the same competance level in any area.”
Obviously, but the Norwegian government does not see this. They want their 40% and, by gosh!, they should have it, no matter the differences in competence levels.
Rolf wrote:
“Fairness is an ongoing consideration throughout the Norweig[a]n society. It is about power sharing.”
That may be so (I serioulsy doubt it), but the government is the one wielding the REAL power, and they are NOT sharing it – just imposing their will on corporations. Next, it will be the individual, and then all Norwegians will be happily collectiverized.
Rolf wrote:
” And for far to long through out the world women have not had their rightfull well deserved place.
The brutes have dominated everywhere and then tried to convince everyone only they were competent. There would be far less kaos and wars in the world if it was women who dominated for I very much doubt that they would be so willing to send their daughters to war to murder other womens daughters.”
Ha ha ha! Considering all the women despots that have been there in history, I seriously doubt things would be THAT different. You are being naïve to the point of pitifulness.
Oh my goodness, Rolf’s posts are nearly as bad as that ADA guy who was in here a while back..
He (she?) should join the feminist party. Then he could complain about how terrible it is for greedy people like us to self-select who we want to work for (and with), and how much better the world would be if went to socialist utopia.
Oh wait! I thought we already tried that. I think it killed a lot of people, too..
Perrosuelto wrote:
“Rolf is absolutely wright. For one, the big nationalist pigs are the americans in general, just see there stupids comments from degenerate people, hoping in an ideal world that NOT EXIST ever under their own empire.”
Se escribe “right”, Perrosuelto, no “wright”. Aprende a escribir de una vez por todas.
And what is with the insult? What degenerate comments are you talking about? The people who write these posts are convinced that freedom and liberty are the answer, and you call them “nationalist pigs”? Have you read mises.org, or are you set into some weird mission to insult American bloggers?
The reason liberty and freedom are not the norm in the USA is due to socialist ideas permeating the government, just like those permeating the Norwegian government.
Perrosuelto wrote:
“Some comments, like despreciate culture, other countries etc. are symptoms of frustrated people that just heard some “egalitarism”-like-behavior, become fould and paranoic.”
They are just commenting on it, Perrosuelto. No need to get exited about it. Also, with your poor grammar you are giving us Latino Americanos a bad rap. Egalitarianism is nothing more than saying: guys who are better than me should be made stupid by government mandate. It is the crab in the bucket mentality, the kind that keeps us Mexicans in the gutter.
Perrosuelto wrote:
“Norvey has all my respect, as any other tradition different to idiot conformism that a society MUST be a pulverized of aggregates individuals.”
Se escribe “Norway”, perrosuelto. Y en español se escribe “Noruega”, para que no pienses que no hablo español.
Societies ARE pulverized aggregates of individuals, Perrosuelto. Each person has a different need, a different view, a different spouse, a different type of dog or cat… You name it. Colectivization has been tried, millions have died due to it, and you want more of it???
I was going to post a reply to the hysterical rantings of Rolf and to a lesser extent Perrosuelto, but Francisco Torres have already provided such good answers that it won’t be necessary.
And Francisco is right, I am from Scandinavia too. Although that means Sweden rather than Norway, I am certainly not criticizing a outside culture (not that I understand why that should be off-limits) since the Swedish government and Swedish society is just as crazed socialist and feminist as the Norwegian (The sad part about this is that the Norwegian government is actually nominally “conservative” unlike the Swedish government who consists of social democrats allied with greens and communists).
Indeed, I believe it is probably just a matter of time before a similar law is implemented in Sweden since the Swedish government have already told Swedish companies “have at least 40% women or else….”, implying legislation if they do not “voluntarily” comply.
One last comment to you Francisco Torres:
You do not live in the Norwegian society, know its history and traditions or speak its language.
You do not know what you are talking about Francisco Torres.
Ta Ta
From Rolf
Rolf wrote:
“One last comment to you Francisco Torres:
You do not live in the Norwegian society, know its history and traditions or speak its language.
You do not know what you are talking about Francisco Torres.”
Disregarding your hollier-than-thou statement, you did not answer the question: WHY does the Norwegian government need to impose a quota on boardroom compositions IF, as you stated, the Norwegian people know their needs better than anybody? If they know what is best for them, why the coercion? Why the arm-twisting?
To be a Norwegian does not give one any special insight on what is sensical and what is utter nonsense, Rolf. You and your fellow Norwegians are not that clever. It is not that difficult to see that this “we know what is best for us” to justify your government’s meddling is pure humbug.
Francisco, a part the ridicolous remarks on the errors in typing, you are a fanatic person: seems to me that you are a mariachi that want to play ALONE instead with a group of 4/5 companeros BECAUSE you have you own spouse or cat. The ranting chorus of mainly people on this argument is not to recognize that one country may chose what he want to do with their life (even voting leaders that impose this kind of thing) To insult foreign behavior on this matter is typically american (look in Sweden are doing like the same) What you want? UNIFORMIZE ALL THE WORLD? How many you are payed to do so? If it’s big money I join immediately myself to some secretive Institutes or Cultural agencies. Say me HOW MUCH, chico! And you look instead into your country, the aberrant Mexico with the caste at the power “Institutional Revolutionary”, the most criminal place in the world, cocksuckers of all it’s USA, beast with bigotes, prostitution, drugs, murderers (first, serach for women in Ciudad Juarez = their wictims female never may enter a administration board) You have to shame to blow up empty propaganda to the world when, a part your chef and some few dozens of squallid exploiters, you spoke from one of the more miserable place in the world. You really think that on obtuse a priori thinking about economy, that is contrasted even by neocons in USA, touch something else that a few poor of sense? When Rolf say put order in you house before, just it’s your case. Don’t put you leg inside other way of think and behave, in other place say Nordic Countries or elsewhere. Otherwise is really stupid, as Lew Rockwell did, attak to war in Iraq. NO ONE WAY THINKING. I don’t discuss your feeling. Don’t want to pay taxes: go to Bahamas, in close to you. What matter you a bigoted mexican with cold Norway?
Ironic that the post intended with the best of humor has devolved into the basest of depravity
Perrosuelto wrote:
“Francisco, a part the ridicolous remarks on the errors in typing, you are a fanatic person: seems to me that you are a mariachi that want to play ALONE instead with a group of 4/5 companeros BECAUSE you have you own spouse or cat.”
Well, I am not a mariachi (I don’t have a tololoche), but if you mean I do not play in a team, well that depends on what you call teamwork. I do not consider having my rights or my money taken at the point of a government threat, as “teamwork”. I am sure all those poor souls that died in the gulags were accused of not playing with the team, either.
Perrosuelto:
“The ranting chorus of mainly people on this argument is not to recognize that one country may chose what he want to do with their life (even voting leaders that impose this kind of thing)”
The problem is that you misunderstand the issue completely, Perrosuelto. If people in Norway really wanted such policy in place, they would have done that by themselves a long time ago instead of having the government impose a quota from above. Even if 51% of the people wanted a 40% women quota on company boardrooms does not make it more ethical than if a despot had imposed the same by him-(or her-)self. There is such a thing as the tyranny of the majority – remember Kristallnacht, 1938.
Perrosuelto:
“What you want? UNIFORMIZE ALL THE WORLD? How many you are payed to do so? If it’s big money I join immediately myself to some secretive Institutes or Cultural agencies. Say me HOW MUCH, chico!”
Uniformization of humans is the staple of socialism and communism, Perrosuelto. I would not wish that even on my best enemy. I think you have your ideas cross-eyed.
Perrosuelto:
“And you look instead into your country, the aberrant Mexico with the caste at the power “Institutional Revolutionary”, the most criminal place in the world, cocksuckers of all it’s USA, beast with bigotes, prostitution, drugs, murderers (first, serach for women in Ciudad Juarez = their wictims female never may enter a administration board). You have to shame to blow up empty propaganda to the world when, a part your chef and some few dozens of squallid exploiters, you spoke from one of the more miserable place in the world.”
The Institutional Revolutionary Party was ousted in 2000 by popular vote, Perrosuelto. It bolsters not your case to say all those mean things about my country, considering many ills are the result of government intervention, not because we are a particularly liberal country.
I never thought we were the “CKSKRS” of the USA, especially since we did not support America on its decision to attack Iraq… As for the most miserable place in the world, I think you are exaggerating just a bit.
Perrosuelto:
“Don’t want to pay taxes: go to Bahamas, in close to you. What matter you a bigoted mexican with cold Norway?”
I prefer to stay in my country and fight for my rights. The last statement I do not understand.
One of your great Mexican poets the poet Octavio Pax said it for both of you, Perrosuelto & Francisco Torres.
Pueblo
Las piedras son tiempo
El viento
Siglos de viento
Los arboles son tiempo
Las gentes son piedra
El viento
Vuelve sobre si mismo y se entierra
En el dia de piedra
No hay agua pero brillan los ojos
English Translation
Village
The stones are time
The wind
Centuries of wind
The trees are time
The people are stone
The wind
Turns upon itself and sinks
Into the stone day
There is no water here for al the lustre of its eyes
By Octavio Pax From Selected Poems 1979
Bilingual edition
Norway, following in Sweden’s footsteps, is imposing a newfangled quota system on companies’ boards of directors selections.
When libertarians, who believe in freedom and in the inviolability of property rights, find that deplorable, one person writes in to complain that that’s an attack on Norwegian “culture.” Another similarly complains it’s an attack on Norwegian “tradition.”
Both writers have it exactly backward. It’s the Norwegian government that’s seeking to make Norwegian culture something different from what it is and has been — by forcing a new way of selecting company board members.
It’s the State attacking the culture and casting off tradition. Why, I wonder, do so many in the world confuse the State with things like culture and tradition — or freedom or patriotism — when most States work overtime to undermine, if not destroy, those very things.
That’s the rhetoric of the State at work: Convince the people that all good things are the handiwork of the State.
Apparently, if you’re not a Norwegian you can’t criticize blatant stupidity on the part of the Norwegian government.
It doesn’t matter that most of the time we’re criticizing the American government, we’re all nationalist pigs because we dare to call this policy what it is: stupid.
Wow! Your website is very interesting site I believe you?re a excellent writer
Comments on this entry are closed.