1. Skip to navigation
  2. Skip to content
  3. Skip to sidebar
Source link: http://archive.mises.org/18917/open-letter-to-the-mayor-of-lviv/

Open Letter to the Mayor of Lviv

November 1, 2011 by

Some may remember the search for and the final success in finding Ludwig von Mises birthplace in the Ukrainian town of Lviv. Then, at the 130th anniversary of Mises’s birth, a conference was organized to celebrate the life and works of Ludwig von Mises. As part of this celebration, a memorial plaque was placed on the wall of the building at 13 Academician V. Hnatiuk Street where Ludwig von Mises grew up.

What happened after the celebration is the typical story of bureaucratic statism. The Standing Committee on Culture, Promotion, Media and Tourism of Lviv City Council, the authority (judging from the name) that is in charge of a bunch of things, ruled that the plaque violated a number of bureaucratic rules and was therefore to be forcefully taken down. So much for Lviv’s great heritage and the historical significance of the birthplace of the greatest economist in the 20th century.

Of course, it is likely that both the “standing committee” and the mayor are quite ignorant of the life and works of Ludwig von Mises. It is also likely that this is but a routine bureaucratic matter that has not gained much attention in the town of Lviv. Therefore, and to express our dissatisfaction with the committee’s decision, an open letter is currently finding its way through the DHL logistics network to the mayor of Lviv, Mr. Andríj Ivanovych Sadovýj. The letter reads (but translated to Ukrainian):

To: Mr. Andríj Ivanovych Sadovýj, Mayor of Lviv;
Cc: Lvivska Miska Rada
Re: Lviv and Ludwig von Mises

30 October 2011

Dear Mr. Sadovýj,
This is to call your attention to a matter of symbolic and practical importance to the City of Lviv and to the countless admirers of one of Lviv’s most famous sons.
Lviv has an enviable history with many great sons and daughters. One of the greatest is no doubt the world renowned economist Ludwig von Mises. Born and raised in Lviv before the family moved to Vienna, Mises is known for many important breakthroughs in economic, monetary, and business cycle theory, the methodology of the social sciences, and for being one of the leading voices in the historically significant socialist calculation debate in the 1920s and 1930s. The numerous and voluminous works of Ludwig von Mises have shaped much of modern economic theory and his many theoretical advances have greatly contributed to both economic and political thinking. Current global financial and monetary challenges have both proven the accuracy of Mises theories and sparked unprecedented interest in his life and works.
By all available records, the Mises family’s industriousness, personal sacrifice and courage had made an extraordinary contribution to the progress and peace of Lviv and Galicia. This was the reason for Ludwig von Mises’s grandfather to be granted a patent of nobility. Considering the great historical and contemporary impact of Ludwig von Mises’s work, and the recent renewed global interest – indeed, a surge – in his work, we would expect the City of Lviv to host annual festivities to commemorate this great man and his achievements, dedicate the town library in his name, or establish a Mises museum to celebrate and document his life. Being the birth town of Ludwig von Mises, the City could venerate and benefit from his deeds and glory.
Yet the actions of the Standing Committee on Culture, Promotion, Media and Tourism of the Lviv City Council are in stark contrast to this great Lvivian heritage. Instead of celebrating their great son of Lviv, the Committee has decided to forcefully remove the plaque that commemorates Mises’s birth home. Such a disregard to Lviv’s own history is hard to comprehend. We can assure you that this motion is interpreted as a gesture of disgrace and bold intransigency.
We hope, Mr. Mayor, that you will be able to convince the Council and your fellow citizens not only to leave Mises’s memorial plaque at the house wall but undertake initiatives to honor his heritage. We remain open for discussion and cooperation for such initiatives.

Per Bylund, The Ludwig von Mises Institute in Sweden
Dr. Krassen Stanchev, Institute for Market Economics
Ruta Vainiene, Lithuanian Free Market Institute

Dr. Roman Mogilevskii, Center for Social and Economic Research CASE-Kyrgyzstan,
Lisl Biggs-Davidson, Center for the Research into post-Communist Economies
Gia Jandieri, New Economic School – Georgia
Dr. John H. Moore. President Emeritus, Grove City College
Mirsuljan Namazaliev, Central Asian Free Market InstituteTsvetelin M. Tsonevski – Foundation for Economic Education
Prof. Miroslav Prokopijevic, Ph.D., IES & European University
Pavel Koktyshev, Institute for Public Policy
Linda N. Newton, Human Resource & Finance, Foundation for Economic Education
Josef Šíma, Ph.D., CEVRO Institute [school of legal and social studies]
Andrei Illarionov, PhD, Institute of Economic Analysis, Cato Institute
PD Dr. Michael Wohlgemuth, Walter Eucken Institut
Dr Alberto Mingardi, Istituto Bruno Leoni,
Prof. Pierre Garello, Aix -Marseille University and Institute for Economic Studies-Europe
Dr. Stefan Kolev, Wilhelm-Röpke-Institute
Jan Oravec, The F.A.Hayek Foundation
Svetozar (Steve) Pejovich, Professor Emeritus, Texas A&M University, Professor, University of Donja Gorica
Vadim Novikov, Russian Academy on National Economy and Public Administration
Dr. Franz-Lothar Altmann, Assoc. Prof.
Prof. Leonard P. Liggio, Atlas Economic Research Foundation
Prof. Donald J. Boudreaux, George Mason University
Dr. Barbara Kolm, F.A.v. Hayek Institut
Martin Zaimov, Chairman, Societe Generale Bulgaria
Carlo Lottieri, University of Siena and Istituto Bruno Leoni
Dr. Tom G. Palmer, Atlas Economic Research Foundation and Cato Institute
Ruzica Stojanovska, Ohrid Institute for Economic Strategies and International Affairs
Pierre Bessard, Liberales Institut, Zurich
Paata Sheshelidze, New Economic School – Georgia
Andreea Mihaela Prundeanu, Academy of Economic Studies
Karl-Peter Schwarz, Franfurter Algemeine Zeitung
Bojan Bogevski, Mises Macedonia
Wolf von Laer, Universidad Rey Juan Carlos
Frederik Cyrus Roeder, Ilia State University
Dr.Muhamet Mustafa, Prof. of Development Management, Pristina Unversity, Kosovo
Konstantin Bondarenko, Tajikistan Free Market Centre
Assoc. Prof. Katarina Zajc, Ph.D., LL.M., University of Ljubljana Law School
Linda Whetstone, Network for a Free Society
Dr. Zef Preci, Albanian Center for Economic Research
Prof. Jörg Guido Hulsmann, Université d’Angers and Ludwig von Mises Institute


Nathan November 1, 2011 at 5:46 pm

I live in L’viv, and this doesn’t surprise me a bit. I guess I should have taken my picture by the plaque while I still had the chance.

Ed November 1, 2011 at 5:47 pm

Please post replies, if any, that you receive. Statism at it’s finest, no doubt.

Per Bylund November 2, 2011 at 6:26 am

It seems some things have changed already. The letter has received quite some attention and more people are signing it and sending copies to the Mayor of Lviv. Also, we have new information saying that there are TWO bureaucratic committees handling this matter, one of which wants to take down the plaque and the other has decided to let it be. Meanwhile, we have the full support of Mr. Remigijus Šimašius, the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Lithuania, who has spoken to the Ukrainian ambassador in Lithuania and expressed his discontent with the issue. It seems the ambassador is to pass on this information to the Mayor of Lviv.

Bartosz Wilk November 3, 2011 at 4:22 am

Why was it disturbing them so much? I will popularize the letter also in Polish Instytut Misesa.

Roman November 3, 2011 at 10:44 am

Having lived in L’viv for a little while, I can say this is most likely an appeal for a bribe. Most businesses there need government connections. Laws in Ukraine are bludgeons used to beat money from people. They don’t even need to be wrapped around a good lie, as in the West.

I’ve blogged about another example here: http://romaninukraine.com/lvivs-historically-approved-abandoned-lots/

Try to run a business in Ukraine in the open and bureaucrats descend upon you like a swarm of flies, looking for money. Step two, is to then argue that Ukraine need more government of the benevolent variety as in the West.

halusnud November 4, 2011 at 12:06 am

The updated Halloween.com is here and now more than ever our mission is to help you enjoy Halloween as much as we do! Since 1994 Halloween.com’s objective has been to help people find useful information about the holiday, while at the same time help those with the information find the people.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: